![the company man ap lang essay Marked by Teachers](https://www.markedbyteachers.com/images/mbt/logo/mbt-logo-sidebar-desktop.png)
- TOP CATEGORIES
- AS and A Level
- University Degree
- International Baccalaureate
- Uncategorised
- 5 Star Essays
- Study Tools
- Study Guides
- Meet the Team
- English Literature
- Criticism & Comparison
- Other Criticism & Comparison
![](http://essaywriter.guru/777/templates/cheerup/res/banner1.gif)
The Company Man Rhetorical Analysis
![the company man ap lang essay Authors Avatar](https://www.markedbyteachers.com/ https://www.markedbyteachers.com/images/mbt/avatars/teacher1.png )
4 th Hour AP Lang & Comp.
January 20, 2009
Rhetorical Analysis of “The Company Man”
In her piece, “The Company Man”, Ellen Goodman uses an arsenal of rhetorical strategies to demonstrate her sentiments towards the main character, Phil -- one of the few, cold individuals able to march robotically through life, frigidly and indifferently pursuing the forever unseen pinnacle of success. Phil, to Goodman, embodies Corporate America.
The descriptions of Phil in The Company Man are sardonically accusatory of the present way people live in society. The author makes light of the fact that Phil is a heart attack waiting to happen, and that he maintains a 70-hour work week, by mentioning the simple fact that he eats egg salad sandwiches. His death is seen as unsurprising by the people who knew him, and they did nothing more than shake their heads when they heard the news. Phil’s character is seemingly insignificant. Goodman mentions that Phil was “fifty-one years old, and a vice president”. With this, she leads the reader to believe that Phil had a very influential role on his company. The subsequent line, however, reveals that “He was, however, one of six vice presidents.” In the ending lines, as well, this portrayal of insignificance reoccurs when the CEO of Phil’s company turns away from telling Phil’s widow that he will be missed, and immediately begins looking for his replacement.
![the company man ap lang essay Join now!](https://www.markedbyteachers.com/images/mbt/adverts/paywall-cta.png)
This is a preview of the whole essay
The article is also littered with statistics. Like many Americans, Phil is constantly obsessed about his work and whether or not he will ascend to the top position. He worked overtime -- 6 day weeks (mostly of 10+ hour days). The 51-year-old was the vice president of a company run by a 60-year-old and was widowed by his 48-year-old wife, who was a simple housewife and mother. Phil’s oldest child was a hard-working executive in a manufacturing firm; his second child, a 24 year old girl—newly married; and his youngest, a high-school graduate who worked just enough to get by. This deliberate emphasis on numerical values is blatant. It exemplifies the importance that Corporate America puts on figures. The leader of Phil’s company was the eldest in the group. Phil, the vice president and next in position of “worth” to the firm, was the next of age. And Phil’s wife, “a good woman with no particular marketable skills”, was the youngest of the group. As for his children, the same social pattern applies. The eldest was the most successful, trickling down to the least successful youngest son. There is also great stress put on the fact that Phil put in an excessive amount of work. However, it is never stated that the work was that of any quality. And when the company president begins the search for Phil’s replacement, he begins by gauging who has been putting in the most work…reinforcing the unjust reality that we judge people by numbers.
Superficially, all seemed well in Phil’s life. His family appeared to live a pleasant existence. In the emotional aspect however, Phil’s family had missed his support for years. When he died, his youngest son strolled the neighborhood, asking neighbors about his father. They were embarrassed to admit that they never really knew him. Phil himself was overweight (although he believed this was okay, since he didn’t smoke), obsessed with work, and as a result, significantly absent in the lives of his children. His wife, Helen, gave up “trying to compete with his work years ago.” And when Phil died “finally and precisely at 3:00 a.m. Sunday morning,” she wasn’t fazed by it. When a company friend says to her, “I know how much you will miss him.” She responds, “I already have.”
Several times the author states that Phil “worked himself to death finally and precisely at 3:00 a.m. Sunday morning.” This forces the reader to pay close attention to Phil’s workaholic life. Phil’s mundane lifestyle is characterized in strict and rigid words such as “always”, “of course”, and “perfect type A”. “Of course,” used several times, translates as the acceptance that people have towards intolerable living conditions in order to fulfill the “American dream”. In addition, expressions such as “overweight”, “worrying”, “nervous”, and “workaholic” depict Phil as a worrywart with no room for fun in his life. Consequently, Phil is established as a man solely obsessed with work, who long ago lost track of his priorities.
To Ellen Goodman, Phil personifies Corporate America. He was a Type A, predictable, and apathetic member of society. His love was not for his family, but for his work. Or rather it was the opportunity for triumph that stirred him. He longed to find the ultimate prize, and immersed himself in obtaining it. But that never happened. For in the end, it was Phil’s lust for success that successfully killed him.
![the company man ap lang essay The Company Man Rhetorical Analysis](https://mbt-essays-prod-public.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/855297/listing/855297_1.jpg)
Document Details
- Word Count 821
- Page Count 3
- Level AS and A Level
- Subject English
Related Essays
![the company man ap lang essay Short Stories Comparison - The Company of Wolves By Angela Carter And Eveline By James Joyce](https://mbt-essays-prod-public.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/74951/listing/74951_1.jpg)
Short Stories Comparison - The Company of Wolves By Angela Carter And Eveli...
![the company man ap lang essay Comment on the writers presentation of loneliness and companionship in the novels The Old Man and the Sea by Hemmingway and The Life of Pi by Martel.](https://mbt-essays-prod-public.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/854633/listing/854633_1.jpg)
Comment on the writers presentation of loneliness and companionship in the...
![the company man ap lang essay Lord Jim is the story of a man named Marlow's struggle to tell and to understand the life story of a man named Jim.](https://mbt-essays-prod-public.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/27317/listing/27317_1.jpg)
Lord Jim is the story of a man named Marlow's struggle to tell and to under...
![the company man ap lang essay Dr Faustus and The Man Who Would Be King on Power](https://mbt-essays-prod-public.s3.eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/134901/listing/134901_1.jpg)
Dr Faustus and The Man Who Would Be King on Power
What are your chances of acceptance?
Calculate for all schools, your chance of acceptance.
![](http://essaywriter.guru/777/templates/cheerup/res/banner1.gif)
Your chancing factors
Extracurriculars.
How to Write the AP Lang Argument Essay + Examples
What’s covered:, what is the ap language argument essay, tips for writing the ap language argument essay, ap english language argument essay examples, how will ap scores impact my college chances.
In 2023, over 550,148 students across the U.S. took the AP English Language and Composition Exam, and 65.2% scored higher than a 3. The AP English Language Exam tests your ability to analyze a piece of writing, synthesize information, write a rhetorical essay, and create a cohesive argument. In this post, we’ll be discussing the best way to approach the argumentative essay section of the test, and we’ll give you tips and tricks so you can write a great essay.
The AP English Language Exam as of 2023 is structured as follows:
Section 1: 45 multiple choice questions to be completed in an hour. This portion counts for 45% of your score. This section requires students to analyze a piece of literature. The questions ask about its content and/or what could be edited within the passage.
Section 2: Three free response questions to be completed in the remaining two hours and 15 minutes. This section counts for 55% of your score. These essay questions include the synthesis essay, the rhetorical essay, and the argumentative essay.
- Synthesis essay: Read 6-7 sources and create an argument using at least three of the sources.
- Rhetorical analysis essay: Describe how a piece of writing evokes meaning and symbolism.
- Argumentative essay: Pick a side of a debate and create an argument based on evidence. In this essay, you should develop a logical argument in support of or against the given statement and provide ample evidence that supports your conclusion. Typically, a five paragraph format is great for this type of writing. This essay is scored holistically from 1 to 9 points.
Do you want more information on the structure of the full exam? Take a look at our in-depth overview of the AP Language and Composition Exam .
Although the AP Language Argument may seem daunting at first, once you understand how the essay should be structured, it will be a lot easier to create cohesive arguments.
Below are some tips to help you as you write the essay.
1. Organize your essay before writing
Instead of jumping right into your essay, plan out what you will say beforehand. It’s easiest to make a list of your arguments and write out what facts or evidence you will use to support each argument. In your outline, you can determine the best order for your arguments, especially if they build on each other or are chronological. Having a well-organized essay is crucial for success.
2. Pick one side of the argument, but acknowledge the other side
When you write the essay, it’s best if you pick one side of the debate and stick with it for the entire essay. All your evidence should be in support of that one side. However, in your introductory paragraph, as you introduce the debate, be sure to mention any merit the arguments of the other side has. This can make the essay a bit more nuanced and show that you did consider both sides before determining which one was better. Often, acknowledging another viewpoint then refuting it can make your essay stronger.
3. Provide evidence to support your claims
The AP readers will be looking for examples and evidence to support your argument. This doesn’t mean that you need to memorize a bunch of random facts before the exam. This just means that you should be able to provide concrete examples in support of your argument.
For example, if the essay topic is about whether the role of the media in society has been detrimental or not, and you argue that it has been, you may talk about the phenomenon of “fake news” during the 2016 presidential election.
AP readers are not looking for perfect examples, but they are looking to see if you can provide enough evidence to back your claim and make it easily understood.
4. Create a strong thesis statement
The thesis statement will set up your entire essay, so it’s important that it is focused and specific, and that it allows for the reader to understand your body paragraphs. Make sure your thesis statement is the very last sentence of your introductory paragraph. In this sentence, list out the key points you will be making in the essay in the same order that you will be writing them. Each new point you mention in your thesis should start a paragraph in your essay.
Below is a prompt and sample student essay from the May 2019 exam . We’ll look at what the student did well in their writing and where they could improve.
Prompt: “The term “overrated” is often used to diminish concepts, places, roles, etc. that the speaker believes do not deserve the prestige they commonly enjoy; for example, many writers have argued that success is overrated, a character in a novel by Anthony Burgess famously describes Rome as a “vastly overrated city,” and Queen Rania of Jordan herself has asserted that “[b]eing queen is overrated.”
Select a concept, place, role, etc. to which you believe that the term “overrated” should be applied. Then, write a well-developed essay in which you explain your judgment. Use appropriate evidence from your reading, experience, or observations to support your argument.
Sample Student Essay #1:
[1] Competition is “overrated.” The notion of motivation between peers has evolved into a source of unnecessary stress and even lack of morals. Whether it be in an academic environment or in the industry, this new idea of competition is harmful to those competing and those around them.
[2] Back in elementary school, competition was rather friendly. It could have been who could do the most pushups or who could get the most imaginary points in a classroom for a prize. If you couldn’t do the most pushups or win that smelly sticker, you would go home and improve yourself – there would be no strong feelings towards anyone, you would just focus on making yourself a better version of yourself. Then as high school rolled around, suddenly applying for college doesn’t seem so far away –GPA seems to be that one stat that defines you – extracurriculars seem to shape you – test scores seem to categorize you. Sleepless nights, studying for the next day’s exam, seem to become more and more frequent. Floating duck syndrome seems to surround you (FDS is where a competitive student pretends to not work hard but is furiously studying beneath the surface just like how a duck furiously kicks to stay afloat). All of your competitors appear to hope you fail – but in the end what do you and your competitor’s gain? Getting one extra point on the test? Does that self-satisfaction compensate for the tremendous amounts of acquired stress? This new type of “competition” is overrated – it serves nothing except a never-ending source of anxiety and seeks to weaken friendships and solidarity as a whole in the school setting.
[3] A similar idea of “competition” can be applied to business. On the most fundamental level, competition serves to be a beneficial regulator of prices and business models for both the business themselves and consumers. However, as businesses grew increasingly greedy and desperate, companies resorted to immoral tactics that only hurt their reputations and consumers as a whole. Whether it be McDonald’s coupons that force you to buy more food or tech companies like Apple intentionally slowing down your iPhone after 3 years to force you to upgrade to the newest device, consumers suffer and in turn speak down upon these companies. Similar to the evolved form of competition in school, this overrated form causes pain for all parties and has since diverged from the encouraging nature that the principle of competition was “founded” on.
The AP score for this essay was a 4/6, meaning that it captured the main purpose of the essay but there were still substantial parts missing. In this essay, the writer did a good job organizing the sections and making sure that their writing was in order according to the thesis statement. The essay first discusses how competition is harmful in elementary school and then discusses this topic in the context of business. This follows the chronological order of somebody’s life and flows nicely.
The arguments in this essay are problematic, as they do not provide enough examples of how exactly competition is overrated. The essay discusses the context in which competition is overrated but does not go far enough in explaining how this connects to the prompt.
In the first example, school stress is used to explain how competition manifests. This is a good starting point, but it does not talk about why competition is overrated; it simply mentions that competition can be unhealthy. The last sentence of that paragraph is the main point of the argument and should be expanded to discuss how the anxiety of school is overrated later on in life.
In the second example, the writer discusses how competition can lead to harmful business practices, but again, this doesn’t reflect the reason this would be overrated. Is competition really overrated because Apple and McDonald’s force you to buy new products? This example could’ve been taken one step farther. Instead of explaining why business structures—such as monopolies—harm competition, the author should discuss how those particular structures are overrated.
Additionally, the examples the writer used lack detail. A stronger essay would’ve provided more in-depth examples. This essay seemed to mention examples only in passing without using them to defend the argument.
It should also be noted that the structure of the essay is incomplete. The introduction only has a thesis statement and no additional context. Also, there is no conclusion paragraph that sums up the essay. These missing components result in a 4/6.
Now let’s go through the prompt for a sample essay from the May 2022 exam . The prompt is as follows:
Colin Powell, a four-star general and former United States Secretary of State, wrote in his 1995 autobiography: “[W]e do not have the luxury of collecting information indefinitely. At some point, before we can have every possible fact in hand, we have to decide. The key is not to make quick decisions, but to make timely decisions.”
Write an essay that argues your position on the extent to which Powell’s claim about making decisions is valid.
In your response you should do the following:
- Respond to the prompt with a thesis that presents a defensible position.
- Provide evidence to support your line of reasoning.
- Explain how the evidence supports your line of reasoning.
- Use appropriate grammar and punctuation in communicating your argument.
Sample Student Essay #2:
Colin Powell, who was a four star general and a former United States Secretary of State. He wrote an autobiography and had made a claim about making decisions. In my personal opinion, Powell’s claim is true to full extent and shows an extremely valuable piece of advice that we do not consider when we make decisions.
Powell stated, “before we can have every possible fact in hand we have to decide…. but to make it a timely decision” (1995). With this statement Powell is telling the audience of his autobiography that it does not necessarily matter how many facts you have, and how many things you know. Being able to have access to everything possible takes a great amount of time and we don’t always have all of the time in the world. A decision has to be made with what you know, waiting for something else to come in while trying to make a decision whether that other fact is good or bad you already have a good amount of things that you know. Everyone’s time is valuable, including yours. At the end of the day the decision will have to be made and that is why it should be made in a “timely” manner.
This response was graded for a score of 2/6. Let’s break down the score to smaller points that signify where the student fell short.
The thesis in this essay is clearly outlined at the end of the first paragraph. The student states their agreement with Powell’s claim and frames the rest of their essay around this stance. The success in scoring here lies in the clear communication of the thesis and the direction the argument will take. It’s important to make the thesis statement concise, specific, and arguable, which the student has successfully done.
While the student did attempt to provide evidence to support their thesis, it’s clear that their explanation lacks specific detail and substance. They referenced Powell’s statement, but did not delve into how this statement has proven true in specific instances, and did not provide examples that could bring the argument to life.
Commentary is an essential part of this section’s score. It means explaining the significance of the evidence and connecting it back to the thesis. Unfortunately, the student’s commentary here is too vague and does not effectively elaborate on how the evidence supports their argument.
To improve, the student could use more concrete examples to demonstrate their point and discuss how each piece of evidence supports their thesis. For instance, they could discuss specific moments in Powell’s career where making a timely decision was more valuable than waiting for all possible facts. This would help illustrate the argument in a more engaging, understandable way.
A high score in the “sophistication” category of the grading rubric is given for demonstrating a complex understanding of the rhetorical situation (purpose, audience, context, etc.), making effective rhetorical choices, or establishing a line of reasoning. Here, the student’s response lacks complexity and sophistication. They’ve simply agreed with Powell’s claim and made a few general statements without providing a deeper analysis or effectively considering the rhetorical situation.
To increase sophistication, the student could explore possible counterarguments or complexities within Powell’s claim. They could discuss potential drawbacks of making decisions without all possible facts, or examine situations where timely decisions might not yield the best results. By acknowledging and refuting these potential counterarguments, they could add more depth to their analysis and showcase their understanding of the complexities involved in decision-making.
The student could also analyze why Powell, given his background and experiences, might have come to such a conclusion, thus providing more context and showing an understanding of the rhetorical situation.
Remember, sophistication in argumentation isn’t about using fancy words or complicated sentences. It’s about showing that you understand the complexity of the issue at hand and that you’re able to make thoughtful, nuanced arguments. Sophistication shows that you can think critically about the topic and make connections that aren’t immediately obvious.
Now that you’ve looked at an example essay and some tips for the argumentative essay, you know how to better prepare for the AP English Language and Composition Exam.
While your AP scores don’t usually impact your admissions chances , colleges do care a lot about your course rigor. So, taking as many APs as you can will certainly boost your chances! AP scores can be a way for high-performing students to set themselves apart, particularly when applying to prestigious universities. Through the process of self-reporting scores , you can show your hard work and intelligence to admissions counselors.
That said, the main benefit of scoring high on AP exams comes once you land at your dream school, as high scores can allow you to “test out” of entry-level requirements, often called GE requirements or distribution requirements. This will save you time and money.
To understand how your course rigor stacks up, check out CollegeVine’s free chancing engine . This resource takes your course rigor, test scores, extracurriculars, and more, to determine your chances of getting into over 1600 colleges across the country!
Related CollegeVine Blog Posts
![the company man ap lang essay the company man ap lang essay](https://blog.collegevine.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/architectural-design-architecture-columns-2100942-150x150.jpg)
![](http://essaywriter.guru/777/templates/cheerup/res/banner1.gif)
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
ENGLISH LANGUAGE 1995 Question 2 (Suggested time—40 minutes. This question counts one-third of the total essay section score.) The following piece, "The Company Man," is by the columnist Ellen Goodman. Read the passage and then write an essay analyzing the rhetorical techniques Goodman uses to convey her attitude toward Phil.
Question 3. The score should reflect a judgment of the essay’s quality as a whole. Remember that students had only. 40 minutes to read and write; therefore, the essay is not a finished product and should not be judged by standards that are appropriate for an out-of-class assignment. Evaluate the essay as a draft, making certain to reward ...
Callahan McArthur 1 Ms. Armstrong AP English 11 23 Sep 2016 Rhetorical Analysis Ellen Goodman’s “The Company Man is about a workaholic named Phil who would spend his free time working himself into his own demise. She uses a few different rhetorical terms to convey her point of view. The author uses irony, sarcastic tone, and symbolism to ...
Mr. Hewitt. January 20, 2009. Rhetorical Analysis of “The Company Man”. In her piece, “The Company Man”, Ellen Goodman uses an arsenal of rhetorical strategies to demonstrate her sentiments towards the main character, Phil -- one of the few, cold individuals able to march robotically through life, frigidly and indifferently pursuing the ...
1 Essays earning a score of 1 meet the criteria for a score of 2 but are undeveloped, especially simplistic in their explanation, or weak in their control of language. 0 Indicates an off-topic response, one that merely repeats the prompt, an entirely crossed-out response, a drawing, or a response in a language other than English.
Download free-response questions from past exams along with scoring guidelines, sample responses from exam takers, and scoring distributions. If you are using assistive technology and need help accessing these PDFs in another format, contact Services for Students with Disabilities at 212-713-8333 or by email at [email protected]. Note ...
piece, “The Company Man.” After reading his paragraph, defend, challenge, or qualify James Baldwin’s ideas about the importance of language as a “key to identity” and social acceptance. Use your observation, experience, or readings. 1996 Read the passage from Lady Mary Wortley Montague’s letter to her daughter.
Open Document. Analysis of Rhetorical Strategies in “The Company Man”. In “The Company Man” by Ellen Goodman, throughout the passage Goodman illustrates her feelings of distaste and anger toward Phil, as he in her mind represents Corporate America: routine, indifferent, almost robotic. Goodman uses numerous rhetorical strategies to ...
2. Pick one side of the argument, but acknowledge the other side. When you write the essay, it’s best if you pick one side of the debate and stick with it for the entire essay. All your evidence should be in support of that one side. However, in your introductory paragraph, as you introduce the debate, be sure to mention any merit the ...
The score should reflect a judgment of the essay’s quality as a whole. Remember that students had only. 40 minutes to read and write; the essay, therefore, is not a finished product and should not be judged by standards appropriate for an out-of-class assignment. Evaluate the essay as a draft, making certain to reward students for what they ...